Ordinary Things

A Kinder Account of Someone Else

Listen on Spotify · Listen on Apple Podcasts

Two days ago you texted a friend about getting together, and you still haven’t heard back. Then you see they posted something online. So they had time for that. You look again at your unanswered invitation, and the silence begins to feel deliberate.

You were looking forward to seeing them. Now you wonder whether you were more eager to get together than they were. Perhaps you reread what you sent. Was the invitation awkward? Did you suggest a day they had already said wouldn’t work? Then the embarrassment turns into irritation. They could at least have answered.

I have done this more often than I would like to admit. It is a strange thing to be hurt by a silence and then notice how much of the hurt I supplied myself.

There is more at stake here than a free evening. An invitation gives away a small piece of what we want. We would like someone's company. We hope they will be pleased that we asked. Most of the time we do this without thinking much about it. When the answer doesn’t come, we become aware of having reached toward someone who has not reached back.

Brené Brown has spent years studying vulnerability and shame. In her book Rising Strong, she describes a painful turn people make after rejection. Someone's failure to love them becomes evidence that they are unlovable. A person's response grows into a judgment about their worth.

An unanswered text is a small thing beside the broken relationships Brown discusses. Still, her observation helps explain why a small silence can become so large. We begin by wondering what happened to our message and end by wondering what we mean to the person who received it. Sometimes an old hurt joins the conversation before the friend has had a chance to reply.

Brown describes vulnerability in terms of uncertainty, risk and emotional exposure. That fits the uncomfortable position of having asked for something we cannot provide for ourselves. We can send the invitation. We cannot supply the welcome. Friendship asks us to live with that dependence on another person's freedom.

It’s tempting to get out of it by deciding what the silence means. Your friend is thoughtless. They only make time when it suits them. You will not bother them again. Now you have a plan, and making it feels better than waiting. Yet the facts haven’t changed. You’ve seen a post online and an unanswered message. You have not heard from your friend.

The explanation begins to affect the friendship. When they finally write, you answer briefly. If they apologize, you are already deciding whether to believe them. They may hear a sharpness they cannot account for. You have been having a conversation about them in your head, and they have arrived halfway through.

Saint Benedict notices what this habit does to the person caught in it. In chapter 64 of his Rule, he warns the abbot against becoming overly suspicious, because he will never be at rest. The abbot has real responsibilities. He cannot simply overlook what goes wrong. Even so, Benedict sees a danger in continually expecting the worst of the people in his care.

There is something familiar about that restlessness. You put the phone down, then pick it up again. You remember the unanswered message. Soon you are reviewing the whole friendship for evidence. By the time your friend replies, an ordinary explanation may sound like an excuse. Suspicion promises some control. Benedict’s warning is that we may find ourselves unable to rest.

Saint Thérèse of Lisieux learned this from the other side. In Story of a Soul, she recalls a time she was the one misread. During recreation, someone came asking for a sister to help with a task. Thérèse was eager to go and had been chosen. But she noticed that the sister beside her wanted to help too, so she put her needlework away slowly and let her neighbor take her place.

Her slowness drew a teasing remark. The community took it for reluctance. Thérèse knew it had been a small kindness, and being misread made her more careful about deciding what other people's actions meant.

We can recognize the same limitation without assuming that every delay conceals a virtue. Someone arrives late, speaks abruptly or declines to help, and we have a piece of information. We also have our own inconvenience, perhaps an old impression of that person, and very little access to the rest of their day. It takes only a moment to join those fragments into a character.

Once the character is settled, contrary evidence can become surprisingly easy to dismiss. Their kindness is unusual. Their apology is convenient. Their explanation is what people like them always say. We continue noticing what they do, but we have stopped allowing it to tell us anything new.

Thérèse's small story unsettles that confidence. It leaves us with the possibility that we have misunderstood even something we watched happen. A kinder account begins to seem less like generosity we bestow on someone and more like honesty about our own limits. We were present. We still did not see everything.

We owe a person care in what we accept as true about them, even when we never say it aloud. An unsupported judgment can injure a friendship long before it becomes gossip. We carry our account into the way we greet them and the patience we give their explanation.

Give the silence the kindest reading you honestly can. You do not know if your friend has been overwhelmed or if the message slipped their mind. Making up an excuse still leaves you telling their story without them. You can acknowledge the disappointment and leave the explanation unfinished.

In the Gospel of Luke, Jesus eats at the house of a Pharisee named Simon. A woman known in the town as a sinner comes to him, weeping, and tends his feet with her tears and ointment. Simon concludes inwardly that a prophet would know what sort of woman was touching him. Her reputation seems to settle the matter.

Jesus directs Simon's attention to the woman's actions, contrasting her care with the hospitality Simon has omitted. He acknowledges her sins and speaks of forgiveness and love. Her past has not made her incapable of responding to grace. Simon knows something about her, but his judgment has kept him from recognizing what she is doing before his eyes.

There is a harder invitation here than simply giving someone the benefit of the doubt. Even when a fault is real, the person remains capable of more than the fault. We can be correct about something they did and still fail to see them truthfully.

That is where the question becomes uncomfortable. Sometimes we would rather have our account confirmed. If the friend really is selfish, we do not have to reconsider the coldness of our reply. If they have always been that way, there is no reason to risk another conversation. An explanation that leaves them entirely at fault asks very little of us.

Hearing them might ask more. We might discover that we misunderstood. We might have to admit that we were hurt, which can feel more exposing than saying we were annoyed. We might hear a criticism of our own conduct. None of those possibilities makes the original disappointment unreal. They do make the conversation less predictable.

The Christian hope is that we are all capable of receiving mercy and changing. We depend on that hope for ourselves. We want our worst response to be something we can acknowledge and grow beyond. It is difficult to ask for such freedom while quietly deciding that another person has shown us all they will ever be.

Thérèse did not think she could manage this on her own. The same chapter that holds her small story also holds her prayer that Christ would love her sisters through her. She knew her limits, and she asked for more than the preference or irritation she happened to feel.

We need that help in relationships that matter to us. Knowing the fair response does not always make us want to give it. We can understand every reasonable explanation and still want the other person to feel our displeasure. We can know we are rehearsing an accusation and return to it anyway. Prayer can begin with that admission.

You wanted to see your friend. You felt foolish when they did not answer. You wanted them to notice that they had hurt you, perhaps without having to tell them. Bring the whole of that to God. There is no need to prepare a more admirable version of yourself before you pray. Ask for enough freedom to speak honestly and enough patience to hear an answer you have not supplied.

Sometimes the honest sentence is very simple. You were looking forward to getting together and were disappointed not to hear back. Your friend can respond to that. They cannot respond well to a charge you have never spoken, especially if every attempt to explain becomes further evidence against them.

Saint Ignatius gave similar advice. When someone is hard to read kindly, ask what they meant. Correction can come later if it is needed. In an ordinary friendship, a short follow-up can do that without turning a missed message into a trial.

There may be no moving explanation. Your friend forgot, or saw the message and put it off. You are allowed to need a little time. Charity does not depend on finding that the other person was innocent after all. It may mean accepting that they were careless this time without rereading the whole friendship as proof that they never cared.

If the pattern continues, you can change what you do. Stop keeping the evening open indefinitely. Ask for an answer by a particular time. Tell them that making plans this way has become difficult. You do not need certainty about their motives before responding to repeated behavior. Benedict asked the same balance of the abbot. Deal with what goes wrong, and do not live expecting the worst. Nor do you owe everyone the same closeness or access to your life. Vulnerability is a risk we take with discernment, not a demand to ignore what experience has taught us.

And when the phone finally lights up, you can read the answer before continuing the argument. You may be right about part of it. You can still let them show you the rest. Someone you wanted to spend time with is speaking. There is still something to learn.

What have I decided about someone that I have not yet learned from them?


Sources and notes

Brené Brown, “The Most Dangerous Stories We Make Up”, an excerpt from Rising Strong, and the transcript of “FFTs”, on vulnerability. Her observations are paraphrased. Their application to an unanswered invitation is the reflection’s own.

Saint Thérèse of Lisieux, Story of a Soul, chapter IX, “The Night of the Soul”, the recreation incident and her prayer for Christ to love through her. Paraphrased from the historical English edition hosted by the Christian Classics Ethereal Library.

Luke 7:36–50, Jesus at Simon’s house. The narrative is paraphrased, with the official USCCB NABRE text consulted. No direct Scripture quotation is reproduced.

Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraphs 2477–2479, on rash judgment, favorable interpretation and human dignity, including Saint Ignatius’s counsel cited in paragraph 2478. Teachings paraphrased.

Adapted from The Rule of Saint Benedict, chapter 64, edited by Brian Junyor (2026), Ordinary Things Press. Copyright © 2026 Brian Junyor. English reading edition licensed under CC BY 4.0. Teaching paraphrased; the application to friendship is the reflection’s own.